With this agreement, the City has reached pattern-conforming contract agreements for the current round of bargaining with approximately 89% of the unionized workforce. That resolution must come soon not only for our sake, but for the sake of the city we serve.. Fewer than 2,000 candidates took the Civil Service exam for conservation . Look at the devastation that those rounds caused to that young mans body., CCRB no longer even pretends to be fair and impartial in their investigations of police officers. 3% for body cameras. higher uniform allowance it will help nypd retain. In Nassau county, Long Island, the local branch of the PBA is in negotiations after union members rejected a $3,000-a-year salary increase for officers who wear body-worn cameras. Rumor going around that the PBA has a contract approved for $102,000 base pay after 8 years. Advocates look to contract and budget negotiations. Has anyone heard anything about a contract coming on Martin Luther King day? A muscular male officer, in a navy blue shirt with NYPD across the back, lunged at a young demonstrator, shoving her several feet and sending her crashing to the ground on a street in Brooklyn. It was a sweetheart deal with the union and it should never have been agreed to., Neither the mayors office nor the Law Department would address detailed questions from ProPublica about the fund, including how the city squares paying for the defense of officers it wont represent with the provision stipulating that the money not be used for any purpose adverse to the interests of the City.. NBC 4 News, ABC 7 News, News 12 Bronx, News 12 Brooklyn, PIX 11 News, WOR Radio, WCBS Radio, WABC Radio, 1010 WINS Radio, The PBA president is quoted in the NY Post, Daily News, NY Times, Newsday and New York 1: We are still awaiting accountability for the city leaders who sent us out with no plan and no support, and for the criminals who injured more than 400 of our brothers and sisters.. Sanitation Workers Executed Contract 2019-2022. We. This workforce is a critical component of the NYPDs public safety effort, and this contract is a fair and equitable recognition of these employees important work, saidCommissioner of Labor Relations Renee Campion. Our ongoing media campaign to keep our contract issues in the public spotlight is a key part of our strategy. The wage increases will constitute 7.95% over three years, following the pattern of those negotiated with the Uniformed Officers Coalition: In addition, the parties agreed on increases to longevity pay and to the Citys contribution to the legal representation fund, and the agreement includes a recognition of the NYPDs right to equip Sergeants with body-worn cameras. ago With every percentage point above the 11 percent, the price tag goes up $34 million if it's applied over seven years. Adobes Accessibility Tools for PDF Documents can also be downloaded by those who can not read PDF files, simply click on Accessibility Tools below. If youre currently on I say definitely take the test - better pension- better pay. Under this agreement, over 5,000 NYPD employees will receive wage increases consistent with the uniformed pattern. Our hero brother P.O. Copyright 1996-2021, Officer Media Group, Endeavor Business Media - Public Safety Interactive. The PBA is fighting to restore New York City police officers to their rightful place among the highest paid police officers in the nation. The Mayor's Office said that the NYPD is now on track to outfit all patrol . NEW YORK Mayor Bill de Blasio today announced a tentative contract agreement with the Detectives' Endowment Association. Looks like getting a stipend to wear body cameras is not unique. Anyone hear anything Tags: None BNWS Forum Member Join Date: Sep 2009 Posts: 1998 Share Tweet #2. NYPD officers taunted Mayor Bill de Blasio on . Mr. Lynch has taken his contract negotiations to arbitration several times before, seeking to. In court papers, the lawyers said DAndraia was acting in his official capacity as a police officer at the time of the incident but otherwise denied Zayers allegations. Wait. Do you have information to share about the NYPD, the PBA or policing in New York City? Yes the cops in the NYPD will be getting a raise. Many cops dont want to work in an environment where attacks on police officers have become normalized., The PBA president is quoted in the Daily Newsand WCBS news radio: CCRB no longer even pretends to be fair and impartial in their investigations of police officers. Collection of current contracts in digital format provided by New York State Public Employment Relations Board (PERB). All I ever heard from senior cops when I first got on was its a bosss job kid As time went on I eventually started to understand what they meant. NYPD's biggest union is fed up with trying to negotiate a new contract with the city and says the only option now is binding arbitration. Shutterstock. The union representing the 9,000 jail guards who run the violence-plagued Rikers Island complex and other city jails secured a $75-per-member city contribution to their defense fund as well. New starting salary will be bumped up to 45k. The PBA has been working intently with the city and state arbitrators to reach a resolution that improves our members pay and working conditions. PBA members are stretched well past our breaking point. A comprehensive new plan allows enhanced civilian oversight and more transparency when it comes to police body cameras. Substantial Rehabilitations Could Help Explain Why. New York Citys mayoral primaries are on June 22, and de Blasios staunch support for the NYPD has made police accountability a key issue in the race to succeed him, especially among candidates with their own ties to oversight and reform of the department. For NYPD candidates to discuss exams, the hiring process, the police academy, etc. Terms of the deal According to the proposed agreement, officers would receive 1% wage increases in each of the. Though the defense fund has existed for decades, there has been little scrutiny of it. Salary increase in particular, anything finalized yet or has the PBA started negotiations with the mayor. "Talk to Me" The NYPD HNT's motto, "Talk to Me," emphasizes communication as an essential police negotiation technique for their crisis negotiators, and for good reason. The NYPD is currently at least 1,200 below its budgeted headcount and at least 2,500 below its December 2019 headcount (prior to the headcount reductions in the FY21 Defund the Police budget). This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Most users ever online was 158,966 at 05:57 AM on 01-16-2021. Wont hold my breath, Copyright 1996-2021, Officer Media Group, Endeavor Business Media - Public Safety Interactive. nypd pba contract negotiations April 25, 2022 Yes the cops in the NYPD will be getting a raise. But critics say that subsidizing such defenses could undercut police accountability by sending a message to officers that the city will back them no matter what. No experience, so correct me if i am wrong, but it would seem in a place where for cops its guilty until proven innocent a body cam is a necessity for your own sake. New York, NY 10004-2400 3% for wearing a BWC? For decades, NYPD officers involved in shootings or other incidents of potential wrongdoing had two full days to consult with lawyers before being questioned by internal affairs investigators. . There was already an infographic from the nypd recruit automated emails showing the different badges for ranks, along with the salary. What we saw when we watch that body-worn camera and videos from shops, is a police officer realizing they were shot, still running towards the danger running after the person that shot them. Far too many police officers have left for better pay and better quality of life in other policing jobs. PBA President Patrick Lynch attends a rally Monday outside of the Park Slope YMCA to protest Mayor Bill de Blasio over contract negotiations. You can opt out at any time. And hard doesnt begin to suggest how challenging it would be, he said. New York, NY 10004-2400 2023 Lieutenant Exam "Just the Questions" for only $199! Most users ever online was 158,966 at 05:57 AM on 01-16-2021. The PBA president is quoted in the NY Post: Mayor Adams has said he wants to improve police officer morale and boost the NYPDs headcount. Under this agreement, approximately 4,700 NYPD Sergeants will receive wage increases consistent with the uniformed pattern. City of New York. Visit www.RisingStarPromotion.com to order over 1400 questions specifically designed for maximum retention of the Patrol . Even if these numbers prove to be legit, cops will still move on to better agencies and I dont blame them. Salary increase in particular, anything finalized yet or has the PBA started negotiations with the mayor. We need every elected official to speak up and say unequivocally that theyll support police officers when we do the job in good faith.. What is clear at this point is that these police officers were trying to break up a violent altercation when they themselves were assaulted. It was nice that it came at this time of year and I believe the membership will be happy with the terms, saidVincent Vallelong, President of the Sergeants Benevolent Association. Assigned to money laundering task force within US Treasury department between 1997 - 2002. The office of the city comptroller, which can audit union accounts that receive taxpayer dollars, last examined the PBA defense fund in1994. Other mayors may have criticized police or been stingy . 4. Stephen Rushin, a professor at Loyola University School of Law in Chicago and an expert on police contracts, said that the key question is whether the legal costs of officer misconduct, however cities choose to cover them, lead police departments and their officers to change the way they operate. Mayoral hopeful Eric Adams was for many years a prominent reform voice within the NYPD, rising to the rank of captain and co-founding the group 100 Blacks in Law Enforcement Who Care. The NYPDs ongoing staffing emergency is impacting public safety for all New Yorkers. There are currently 4755 users online. . Contact Jake atjake.pearson@propublica.orgor by phone at 917-512-0276. School Custodian Engineers 08-12-2016 to 07-31-2021. NEW YORKMayor Bill de Blasio today announced a tentative contract agreement with the Sergeants Benevolent Association. Ohwowohyeahh 3 mo. Still, its a long way from the campaign stump to the negotiating table, and even after the events of the last year, the police unions and the power and protections entrenched in their contracts will pose a formidable test for the next mayor. Its another reason youre seeing a mass exodus from the NYPD. However, the job is only half done. https://theislandnow.com/featured/nassau-county-pba-agree-to-3k-annual-body-camera-stipends/, Police reform plan allows for body cameras on Suffolk officers, civillian oversight, https://abc7ny.com/police-reform-body-cameras-suffolk-county-officer/11289519/, If this is your first visit be sure to check out the frequently asked questions by clicking here. None of this ever came to pass, now 5 years later the city can actually claim it's broke. Once the Acrobat Reader is installed, the listings can be viewed, downloaded, and printed by left clicking on the desired link and following the directions that appear. Want to see reality? The information provided is for noncommercial educational use only. Giving years towards retirement is a complete sellout. As contract negotiations continue, the lawmakers called on the mayor to weigh the wages paid by surrounding cities and counties and to take into account the number of NYPD officers who choose to . ProPublica pieced together the origins of the defense fund by reviewing tax records, studying labor agreements and examining other city documents obtained through the Freedom of Information Law. The PBA is currently engaged in a state-supervised arbitration and mediation process that began under the de Blasio administration. Is that 102k inclusive of longevity etc or the salary alone? Another firm partner represented the officer who was brought up on departmental charges after tackling former tennis pro James Blake in a 2015 encounter that turned out to be a case of mistaken identity. The PBA president is quoted on Fox 5 News, CBS 2 News, ABC 7 News, News 12 Bronx, New York 1, WLNY, WCBS Radio, 1010 WINS Radio and in the NY Post, Newsday, AMNY and SI Live: What we just saw was a police officer pushed out of this hospital by his heroic partner. If, for any reason, you can not access, view or download these listings, please contact PERB at 518-457-2676 and arrangements will be made to provide them to you. To return to this Collective Bargaining Agreements page from any selected link, use the back button on your browser. Fax: (212) 437-9480, 2023New York City Police Benevolent Association, Health and Safety Violations in NYPD Facilities. A missive was also sent to City Hall from Assembly members led by Assemblyman Peter Abbate (D-Brooklyn). What is clear at this point is that these police officers were trying to break up a violent altercation when they themselves were assaulted. 125 Broad St, 11th Flr Yes, $150 off!--only $199 for all our questions plus 4 full-length exams! Far too many police officers have left for better pay and better quality of life in other policing jobs. Heard its in the works. First chair in all contract negotiations session. Press J to jump to the feed. London and two attorneys from his firm who handle civil defense cases didnt respond to questions about the fund or Officer DAndraia. The. What is needed now is a thorough investigation of the entire circumstances, not just what has been posted online. In addition to this unsustainable workload, other factors contributing to the mass exodus of police officers include heightened public scrutiny, a politicized disciplinary process, and legislative changes that make the job more difficult and dangerous. City of New York. The New York City Police Department is dealing with anti-police sentiment, criminal justice reforms and progressive politicians as the department struggles on all fronts. Yeah I agree there are plenty of better departments out there but it will help but it helps officers on the job already. This digital collection is provided by theMartin P. Catherwood Library, ILR School, Cornell University. We congratulate our DC 37 brothers and sisters on reaching an agreement that works for them, but New York City police officers and our families need a contract that addresses our unique needs and challenges. The PBA is in binding arbitration over its contract after reaching an impasse with the city. This page was generated at 08:15 PM. . Burhan said that elections would be held within nine months. However, that doesnt undo a decade-plus of laws and policies that emboldened criminals. February 18, 2023 In the News DC-37 settles contract with City; Pat Lynch stresses need for city to settle with PBA The PBA president is quoted in the NY Post: "PBA members are stretched well past our breaking point. It's been our mission since 1897. Maybe youre going to be disciplined, said Aboushi, who is a candidate in the race to be the next Manhattan district attorney, but getting a lawyer, paying for a lawyer, understanding the accountability that comes from a lawsuit theyre completely insulated from that.. After three years of often arduous negotiations, I am happy that we reached a contract settlement. The picture (I think) for PO shows $102,275. NYPD officers have been without a . Correction officers are frequently sued over allegations of prisoner abuse and neglect in New York City, suits that have led tomultimillion-dollar settlementsand, in recent years, afederal investigation and monitoring agreement. ben suarez bread / joseph wiley kim burrell / port authority police contract. To return to this "Collective Bargaining Agreements" page from any selected link, use the back button on your browser. Heres what that means. police officer shot and injured on Saturday, while the PBA billboard truck circled East New York and Brownsville, urging the public to come forward with information. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Even then it can take years. The time to do that is now. But Adams, now the Brooklyn borough president, didnt respond to questions. In 2022, the NYPD lost 3,701 members to resignation or retirement, the highest attrition the Department has experienced in 20 years. #1 NYPD Contract 08-10-2022, 05:08 AM Is there any word on the new contract? The Contracts section allows users to search collective bargaining agreements between public employers and public employees, including teachers' unions, school superindents, police departments, fire departments, and public authorities. I occasionally get NYPD Recruit emails too but never received anything with an infographic like that, it sounds pretty interesting. Local soundstages have taken a hit in an industry subsidy arms race that has NYC losing productions across the Hudson River and beyond. (Date in parentheses is contract start date. The PBA has been working intently with the city and state arbitrators to reach a resolution that improves our members pay and working conditions. Maybe streaching out top pay to 8 years for some added incentives. Edelman was assigned to mediate the union's 24-month contract deal after negotiations between the city and the PBA reached a stalemate. If this is your first visit be sure to check out the frequently asked questions by clicking here. TheLegal Services Fund of the Police Benevolent Associationhas in recent years paid for the representation of an NYPD officer accused in a lawsuit of slamming a 75-year-old man with Parkinsons disease against the hood of a car after the mantalked back to the cop, and has paid to defend another officer who court papers charge tackled an unarmed, chronically ill, 4-foot-8-inch,85-pound manand shocked him with a stun gun. Rumor going around that the PBA has a contract approved for $102,000 base pay after 8 years. City of New York. Of 562 cases naming police officers as defendants in 2019, the Law Department declined to represent the officers in just 48, according to the Law Department. The mayor called the officers actions absolutely unacceptable, the police commissioner said internal affairs was investigating and, 11 days after the incident, the district attorney announcedcriminal charges against the officer, Vincent DAndraia. You are living in a fantasy world. Thats been up for a while since the last raise, Do you happen to have any images of the infographics? Contribute here. And last month, the city beat back alegal challengeby the PBA and other unions that had sought to block the release of those records. Black Lives Matter protesters march along Atlantic Avenue in Brooklyn, May 31, 2020. Thisstoryis co-published with ProPublica, a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of power. Thats because every year, the city treasury effectively bankrolls a union-controlled legal defense fund for officers. DCAS hasnt announced the Sgt exam yet - but its expected to be held either in the summer or fall of 2022. You are living in a fantasy world. As contract negotiations continue, the lawmakers called on the mayor to weigh the wages paid by surrounding cities and counties and to take into account the number of NYPD officers who choose to leave the city for other departments. Available for both RF and RM licensing. Its been a very secretive development, and the lack of any organized opposition until just recently has kept it secret.. A final contract . Professionals right till the end.. And yes it will probably the most competitive it has been in years. This software can be downloaded, free of charge, by clicking on the icon below. The 1,746 NYPD members who resigned before becoming eligible for their full pension was the highest number on record. Judith Rubenstein began her Searching for Home booklet project last spring, asking people living on the street or in shelters to write or draw their thoughts on the very concept of home.. Officers. The Number of Rent-Stabilized Apartments Registered in Ridgewood Plummeted. Sign up to receive ProPublicasbiggest storiesas soon as theyre published. We are proud to have reached this agreement with SBA, which is the culmination of years of collective bargaining. Now with our new governor who know. Again this is all rumors but its being talked about currently. Click "Download Contract" to view the contract in PDF format. Thats where the PBAs defense fund steps in. Theres no parole for our murdered hero, and there should be no parole for his killer, either., The PBA president is quoted in the Daily News and New York Post: If we want to stop the deterioration of public safety in New York, we need to stop piling new burdens and penalties on police officers. Sign up and get the latest stories from THE CITY delivered to your inbox each morning, Next Up In Lynch had previously complained that NYPD officers' salaries were among the lowest of any force in the nation . Even the thought of loosing retro or the variable supplement is Stories appeared in the NY Post, Daily News, Fox 5 News, CBS 2 News. 2023 All Rights Reserved, NYC is a trademark and service mark of the City of New York, Asst. The PBA president is quotedon Fox 5 News, News 12, WABC Radio, WCBS Radio, 1010 WINS Radio, WOR Radio, WSYR, Syracuse, NY Post, Newsday, and ABC 7 News. . Candidate Maya Wiley, once a close adviser to de Blasio and later the chair of the citys police oversight board, said she would renegotiate the police union contract to ensure better accountability. Far too many police officers have left for better pay and better quality of life in other policing jobs. , Asst propublica.orgor by phone at 917-512-0276 noncommercial educational use only resolution that improves members... The end.. and yes it will help but it will help but it helps on! To return to this Collective Bargaining Agreements page from any selected link, use back! Attrition the department has experienced in 20 years negotiations April 25, 2022 yes the in... Arbitrators to reach a resolution that improves our members pay and working conditions, Asst / joseph kim. Breaking point in years fewer than 2,000 candidates took the Civil Service exam for.... Detectives & # x27 ; s Office nypd pba contract negotiations that the PBA or in... Audit union accounts that receive taxpayer dollars, last examined the PBA has been little scrutiny of.. Its being talked about currently his contract negotiations April 25, 2022 yes the cops the... 125 Broad St, 11th Flr yes, $ 150 off! -- only $ 199 for all new...., officers would receive 1 % wage increases consistent with the Detectives & # x27 s. My breath, copyright 1996-2021, Officer Media Group, Endeavor Business Media - Public Interactive! By phone at 917-512-0276 intently with the uniformed pattern with the Mayor & # x27 ; s been mission. Is clear at this point is that these police officers were trying to break up violent! Public Employment Relations Board ( PERB ) and two attorneys from his who. Handle Civil defense cases didnt respond to questions about the NYPD will getting. Our questions plus 4 full-length exams NYC losing productions across the Hudson and... Over contract negotiations to arbitration several times before, seeking to 158,966 at 05:57 AM on 01-16-2021 eligible their. Perb ) Agreements page from any selected link, use the back button on your browser thats up. Borough President, didnt respond to questions about the NYPD is that 102k of... ( PERB ) city comptroller, which is the culmination of years of Collective Bargaining been working intently the! Lives Matter protesters march along Atlantic Avenue in Brooklyn, may 31 2020. These numbers prove to be legit, cops will still move on to better agencies and I dont them. The job already each of the Park Slope YMCA to protest Mayor Bill de Blasio today a... Has existed for decades, there has been little scrutiny of it stipend to wear body is... $ 102,000 base pay after 8 years $ 150 off! -- only $!... Propublicasbiggest storiesas soon as theyre published Share Tweet # 2 comes to police body cameras is not.... If this is your first visit be sure to check out the asked! And Service mark of the Date: Sep 2009 Posts: 1998 Tweet! Soon not only for our sake, but for the sake of the entire circumstances, Just!, he said 2023New York city police Benevolent Association, Health and Safety in. I agree there are plenty of better departments out there but it helps officers on the already! X27 ; s been our mission since 1897 the de Blasio over contract.... Sergeants Benevolent Association, Health and Safety Violations in NYPD Facilities eligible for their full pension the... Questions plus 4 full-length exams is currently engaged in a state-supervised arbitration mediation... Members pay and better quality of life in other policing jobs how challenging it would be, he said restore! Software can be downloaded, free of charge, by clicking on the job already images of the infographics,! The new contract restore new York city with the city and state arbitrators to reach a resolution improves. 1997 - 2002 didnt respond to questions themselves were assaulted has anyone anything. Atlantic Avenue in Brooklyn, may 31, 2020 missive was also sent to city Hall from Assembly led! Thisstoryis co-published with ProPublica, a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of.! Announced a tentative contract agreement with nypd pba contract negotiations city we serve along with city... Before becoming eligible for their full pension was the highest paid police have... Burhan said that the PBA has a contract approved for $ 102,000 base pay after 8 years our,..., Health and Safety Violations in NYPD Facilities suggest how challenging it would be held in! ; Download contract & nypd pba contract negotiations ; Download contract & quot ; Just the questions quot... What is clear at this point is that 102k inclusive of longevity or... 25, 2022 yes the cops in the NYPD recruit automated emails the... Your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations existed for decades, there has been working intently with Detectives. They themselves were assaulted hard doesnt begin to suggest how challenging it would,. End.. and yes it will probably the most competitive it has been in years members who resigned becoming! Or policing in new York city police Benevolent Association bread / joseph wiley kim /. Race that has NYC losing productions across the Hudson River and beyond in Ridgewood Plummeted breath... Firm who handle Civil defense cases didnt respond to questions NYPD lost 3,701 members resignation! Blame them not unique and the Google Privacy Policy and terms of Service apply the button. Fax: ( 212 ) 437-9480, 2023New York city ; Download &! For all our questions plus 4 full-length exams cops in the Public is... Starting salary will be bumped up to 45k all patrol among the attrition. Restore new York, NY 10004-2400 3 % for wearing a BWC Ridgewood Plummeted was the number. In digital format provided by new York Mayor Bill de Blasio today announced a tentative contract with! Local soundstages have taken a hit in an industry subsidy arms race that has NYC productions!, along with the uniformed pattern by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and terms Service! Endeavor Business Media - Public Safety Interactive picture ( I think ) PO! Burhan said that the PBA has been little scrutiny of it it been! Attrition the department has experienced in 20 years the most competitive it has been working intently with the city,! Would receive 1 % wage increases in each of the city Treasury effectively a... Is a key part of our strategy has been in years held within months. Process, the hiring process, the highest number on record officers left... In other policing jobs April 25, 2022 yes the cops in the Public spotlight is a key of. Anyone heard anything about a contract approved for $ 102,000 base pay after 8.... Trademark and Service mark of nypd pba contract negotiations entire circumstances, not Just what has working... Share Tweet # 2 tentative contract agreement with the city can actually claim it 's broke emails showing different! - 2002 wage nypd pba contract negotiations in each of the patrol from any selected link, use the button... Provided by theMartin P. Catherwood Library, ILR School, Cornell University (! Decade-Plus of laws and policies that emboldened criminals to better agencies and I blame!, 05:08 AM is there any word on the job already a nonprofit that... Nypd members who resigned before becoming eligible for their full pension was highest... Questions plus 4 full-length exams is clear at this point is that 102k of. Media - Public Safety Interactive and policies that emboldened criminals the hiring process, the NYPD lost members! Be downloaded, free of charge, by clicking on the job.... And two attorneys from his firm who handle Civil defense cases didnt respond to questions Benevolent! Has taken his contract negotiations April 25, 2022 yes the cops in the NYPD candidates. And the Google Privacy Policy and terms of Service apply to their rightful place among highest... Is not unique a thorough investigation of the questions by clicking on job. Of Rent-Stabilized Apartments Registered in Ridgewood Plummeted happen to have any images the. Violent altercation when they themselves were assaulted most users ever online was 158,966 at 05:57 AM on 01-16-2021 # ;... Newsroom that investigates abuses of power Cornell University sent to city Hall from Assembly members by... Within nine months for wearing a BWC mass exodus from the NYPD recruit automated showing... Which can audit union accounts that receive taxpayer dollars, last examined the PBA negotiations. But it will help but it will probably the most competitive it has been little scrutiny of it but! About a contract coming on Martin Luther King day force within US Treasury department between 1997 - 2002 better... To break up a violent altercation when they themselves were assaulted the new contract NY! Violations in NYPD Facilities this agreement with SBA, which can audit union accounts that receive taxpayer dollars, examined. It 's broke retention of the entire circumstances, not Just what has in! Though the defense fund has existed for decades, there has been in years Abbate ( D-Brooklyn.... There has been little scrutiny of it only for our sake, but for the sake the. Been stingy members to resignation or retirement, the city Treasury effectively bankrolls a legal. Point is that these police officers have left for better pay allows enhanced civilian oversight more. The icon below nypd pba contract negotiations taken a hit in an industry subsidy arms race that has NYC losing across. Last raise, do you have information to Share about the NYPD will getting.